Heritage coatings on Kidderpore Avenue
Heritage coatings on Kidderpore Avenue follow the grade II* Church of St Luke, grade II Kidderpore Hall and the Voysey flank of Annesley Lodge.
Three designations in a short stretch of road
At the top of Kidderpore Avenue stands a row of buildings of exceptional quality: the Gothic Revival Church of St Luke, St Luke's Vicarage, and the side of Annesley Lodge, which is an Arts and Crafts house by Voysey. The Church of St Luke is listed grade II* under list entry 1379248. Further down, Kidderpore Hall at Kings College is listed grade II under list entry 1379250, within a complex of listed buildings in red brick, stone and render with Classical, Queen Anne and other elements, including an Ionic portico.
Heritage decorating in that company starts with paperwork and ends with a brush, not the other way round. For a grade II* or grade II building the consent position is established in writing before a specification is issued, and the specification itself is written so a conservation officer could read it without translation. A decorator working on an unlisted house beside the row still needs to know what the row is, because dust, scaffolding and overspray are indifferent to boundaries and a neighbouring grade II* wall is not.
A grade II* church and a listed college complex are not one specification. Hampstead Renovations cover listed-building work, and communal courtyards and their shared areas can be taken to Hampstead Chartered Surveyors, our sister surveying and building consultancy firm.
Working inside a listed residential complex
The arrangement of the Kings College buildings creates enclosed courtyards within the complex, and the college is now residential. A courtyard changes four practical things at once. Access is through a single route, so deliveries and removals are timed rather than continuous. Sound reflects off the enclosing walls, which matters when people are at home. Air moves less, so drying is slower and ventilation during internal work needs thought. And the finished elevations are seen close up from the windows opposite rather than from across a road.
Red brick, stone and render in one complex means three substrates in one scheme. The render is the surface that can take a breathable masonry coating. The stone is washed and left unless it has carried paint for generations, in which case it is maintained as a painted element. The brick stays brick. An Ionic portico is the sort of feature where paint history should be checked before anything is removed, because the layers themselves are evidence of how the building was finished.
Mortar first, coatings second
In some building refurbishments across the Redington/Frognal Conservation Area cement mortar appears to have been used, and Camden's warning is that it may have implications for the bricks by locking moisture in and leading to erosion. On a road the appraisal calls arguably the most architecturally interesting in the conservation area, that warning deserves acting on. Before any masonry coating is considered, the pointing is looked at: soft lime joints that are weathering back are doing their job, hard grey joints standing proud of eroded brick arrises are not.
Where cement pointing is present, the honest heritage recommendation is to keep coatings off the masonry altogether and to raise the mortar as a separate repair question. A vapour-open finish helps a wall that can still breathe; it cannot rescue one whose joints have been sealed. Saying so costs a decorator work in the short term and saves the owner a wall in the long term, which is the trade a heritage specification is supposed to make.
Plain tile, small panes and the Arts and Crafts detail
The lower section of Kidderpore Avenue has properties of two to four storeys in red brick and plain tile, with some render and small pane timber framed windows, and those houses have an Arts and Crafts character with gables, dormers, porches, tile hanging, tall chimneys and angled corners. In Arts and Crafts work the materials are meant to be seen as themselves: tile as tile, brick as brick, timber as timber under a finish that does not pretend to be something else. A heritage scheme that respects that will look thinner on paper and better on the building.
Windows in the conservation area are mainly timber, with metal framed windows in some mid-20th century properties, and on this avenue the timber ones often carry small panes. Keeping an original small paned sash serviceable is mostly putty, primer and local timber repair, done opening by opening. Replacing it is the decision that cannot be reversed, and on a street of this quality it is the decision that needs the strongest reason.
What a heritage proposal for this avenue contains
It contains names. The Church of St Luke with its grade II* entry. Kidderpore Hall with its grade II entry. The Voysey flank of Annesley Lodge as a neighbour to be protected rather than a surface to be treated. It contains a window schedule recording material, style, number of lights and condition. It contains a note on the mortar. And it contains a list of surfaces that will deliberately not be coated: sound brick, plain tile, tile hanging, and stone that has never been painted.
What it does not contain is a figure for a durability period, a product endorsement or a promise about how long a finish will last on a particular wall. Those depend on exposure, substrate and maintenance, and none of them can be known from a survey. What can be promised is the sequence: establish consent, repair what is failing, prepare properly, coat only what should be coated, and write down what was done so the next person has something to work from.
Heritage coating questions on Kidderpore Avenue
Which buildings on the avenue are listed?
The Church of St Luke is listed grade II* under list entry 1379248, and Kidderpore Hall at Kings College is listed grade II under list entry 1379250, within a complex of listed buildings in red brick, stone and render with Classical, Queen Anne and other elements including an Ionic portico. The top of the avenue also includes St Luke's Vicarage and the side of Annesley Lodge, an Arts and Crafts house by Voysey. Work on or next to any of those begins with the consent position in writing.
Does a breathable coating suit an Arts and Crafts front here?
It suits the render, and nothing else. The lower section of the avenue is red brick and plain tile with some render and small pane timber framed windows, and the houses carry tile hanging among their Arts and Crafts features. Vapour-open systems let a finished wall dry outwards, which is why they belong on render. On plain tile, tile hanging and sound facing brick they would bridge the surfaces that are already shedding and drying water, and that does harm rather than good.
Why does the pointing get checked before the coating is chosen?
Because it decides whether a coating is advisable at all. Camden records that cement mortar appears to have been used in some building refurbishments in the conservation area, and warns that it may have implications for the bricks by locking moisture in and leading to erosion. If the joints have been sealed with cement, moisture leaves through the brick face, and a film on that face has nowhere to let it go. On a wall in that condition the recommendation is to keep the masonry uncoated and treat the mortar separately.
Sources
Related reading
- Heritage and breathable coatings, and the substrates that suit them
- Back to the Kidderpore Avenue place page and its sourced facts
- Heritage coatings on Redington Road and its Philip Webb pair
- Heritage coatings on Fitzjohn's Avenue, where listings take in the boundary
- Heritage coatings on Church Row, the listed walk by the village church
- What conservation area status means for decorating decisions
A heritage proposal for Kidderpore Avenue names the listings, records the windows opening by opening, and is explicit about the surfaces that will be left exactly as they are. Ask about heritage work on Kidderpore Avenue.